A strange thing is occurring in Vietnam: while businesses declare big losses or bankruptcy, banks still make big money.
Bankers strong, businesses weak
In a healthy economy, banks pump capital into production. After production generates profits, capital is returned back to banks which then lend to businesses to create bigger profits. This means that there always exists a close link between the production and the capital, between enterprises and bankers.
However, a strange thing is occurring in Vietnam: while a lot of businesses have gone bankrupted in the big economic difficulties, bankers still stay safe from the crisis.
A lot of businesses have reported bad business performance for 2011 and loss in this year’s shareholders’ meeting season. Meanwhile, most banks have reported big losses at shareholders’ meetings.
Dr Le Dat Chi from the HCM City Economics University said that for a long time, the banking system has not paid much attention to lending to the production sector. Instead, they have been pouring capital into the stock market and real estate market which can bring higher profits and faster capital turnover
Chi said that when the banking system cannot support the development of businesses, this means that the national economy suffers from diseases and it needs prescription to treat the diseases.
In fact, the State Bank has admitted that there are some weak banks which need to be restructured. Some economists have suggested that it would be better to let the banks get bankrupted. In principle, bank is also a business, and like other types of businesses, banks should also be dissolved when they do not have capability.
Dr Vu Thanh Tu Anh, Director of the Fulbright Economic Teaching Program, has warned that the determination by the government not to let any banks go bankrupted and any bankers lose their stockholder equity may create a “reverse effect.”
The merger of the first three banks in Vietnam, which was announced in late 2011, was a typical example. In this case, the owners of the banks did not lose their stockholder equity. Especially, they have even got the capital pumped by the State Bank. This would prompt other banks to follow the move.
“As a result, the action by the State Bank may erode the confidence on the banking system and the national economy,” Tu Anh said.
A question has been raised about who would “take on” the weak banks which need restructuring. In other countries in the world, the governments would spend money to buy stakes of banks to obtain the right to control the banks. After the banks can make profits, the governments would resell the banks to investors. Meanwhile, it proves to be unfeasible to call on investors to spend money to take over the banks which have been in bad conditions.
Some big banks have stated that they are ready to receive smaller banks if they are requested, or to cooperate with other banks for a better development. Dang Van Thanh, President of Sacombank, has affirmed that Sacombank has got ready for the cooperation deals. Ten years ago, Thanh Thang Bank was successfully merged into Sacombank.
The government has announced it may consider allowing foreign credit institutions to buy Vietnamese banks and raise the foreign ownership ratio limits at the banks.
Nevertheless, Le Xuan Nghia, a well-known financial analyst, has warned that it would be very difficult to call for foreign investment into weak banks.
In fact, merger is chosen by banks only when they cannot find other feasible solutions, because they would have to undergo very complicated procedures to be merged into others, while the legal framework on the issue still shows many problems.
Some banks have decided to cooperate with other banks in some fields, rather than wholly merging into others. ACB, for example, has signed a memorandum of understanding with Standard Chartered Bank on a cooperation plan, under which ACB’s personal clients would enjoy many benefits and services of the bank.
|< Prev||Next >|
» SBV explains changes to personal loan limit
» In a bind
» Greek debt crisis: Banks to reopen after three-week shutdown
Latest Category Posts
- VN tops ASEAN with number of new domains
- M&A market boom expected to continue
- Quang Ninh, HCM City join hands to develop tourism
- FDI enterprises promote use of Vietnamese goods
- Dak Lak to replace fields of aging coffee trees
- Blue chips undercut market again
- JETRO supports Ha Giang province in investment attraction
- Measures taken to bolster export of agro-forestry-aquatic products
- Soc Trang turns sea-borne economy into major pillar
- PM approves import management project
Random Category Picks
- With farms, fruit and feed, Vietnam's tycoons explore agribusiness ventures
- Indochina Land sells Indochina Plaza Hanoi, Hyatt Regency Danang
- Australia grabs Vietnam cattle market by the horns
- Robusta coffee swings to backwardation amid Vietnam supply fears
- Samsung once again haggles over investment incentives
- Australia bullish on Vietnam’s beef market
Popular Category Posts
- Boom of shopping centers in eastern HCM City
- Vietnamese lychees promoted widely abroad, at home
- Keangnam to sink deeper into trouble
- Vietnam enterprises must be ready for trade barriers abroad, self-defense at home: experts
- Hong Kong businesses interested in Phu Quoc Island
- Quang Ninh looks to attract Japanese investment
- Vietnam pours $20 billion abroad
- Local-foreign consortium to develop fertilizer complex
- Hotels under pressure as market dips
- HCM City's enterprises eye Myanmar market
- In Vietnam, US dollar appreciation makes some quite happy, leaves others in trouble
- Where have $20 billion worth of Chinese imports gone?
- Vietnam-Mexico business forum opens
- Chinese try to corner farm produce market in Vietnam
- Figures on luxury cars reveal wealth of Vietnamese upstarts
- Lychee exports to Australia off to great start
- Chinese firms interested in purchasing bulk Vietnamese farm produce
- Local steel exports thrive in Pakistan
- FIEs remain tight-lipped in technology transfers
- Vietnamese consumers are world’s most thrifty: Nielsen survey